Study of 10 countries finds farmers see savings from year one, but yields can take three to five years to recover
By Bunmi Yekini
Farming methods that work with nature can deliver yields comparable to or higher than industrial agriculture across Africa, while cutting costs and helping farmers cope with climate shocks, according to a study released on Friday by the charity ActionAid.
The report, “Adapt to Thrive”, draws on research from Ethiopia, the Gambia, Ghana, Kenya, Malawi, Nigeria, Tanzania, Uganda, Zambia and Zimbabwe. It was published to coincide with World Food Day.
ActionAid said public money still flows mostly to industrial inputs. In 2023-24, subsidies for largely imported synthetic fertiliser and hybrid seeds took up 80% of Zambia’s agricultural budget and 50% of Zimbabwe’s, even though both countries are developing agroecology strategies.
“This study brings together evidence from ten African countries showing that agroecology is both a climate solution and a profitable economic choice,” said Arthur Larok, secretary-general of ActionAid International.
Agroecology, which combines ecological science with farmers’ traditional knowledge, is not a single set of practices. The report says it covers measures such as crop rotation, composting, natural pest control and saving indigenous seed.
Yield and profit claims
The report cites a 41% average rise in cereal yields from rotating legumes with cereals across sub-Saharan Africa. It also cites an almost threefold increase in pigeon pea and sorghum yields in Tanzania, and maize yields up to twice as high in Zambian demonstration plots.
Studies in Kenya found an average 37.8% rise in profits after a one-to-three-year transition, the report said.
It acknowledged that the switch is not painless. Yields can fall or fluctuate at first, by an indicative 10% to 35% depending on soil condition. Farmers can take three to five years to match conventional output, and labour needs rise during the transition.
“Farmers cannot be expected to carry the risks of transition alone,” said Constance Okeke, an ActionAid project manager and one of the report’s coordinators.
Farmers’ experience
In Msanga village in Tanzania’s Dodoma region, farmers have set up a community seed bank and two seed farms to preserve indigenous crops. Farmer Janeth Nyamayahasi said she harvested 12 bags of maize last season from a field that previously yielded four.
“When we protect our seeds, we protect our food, our culture, and our future,” she said.
Women and climate
The report says agrifood systems account for 66% of women’s employment in sub-Saharan Africa. It cites UN Food and Agriculture Organization data showing that closing gender gaps in productivity and wages could add nearly $1 trillion to global GDP and leave about 45 million fewer people food insecure.
It also cites studies finding agroecological farms can be two to four times more energy efficient than conventional ones, and says they stabilise yields in dry spells.
Calls for action
ActionAid called on African governments to:
- meet their pledge to spend at least 10% of national budgets on agriculture
- direct at least 30% of agricultural spending to agroecological approaches by 2035
- shift at least a third of subsidies away from industrial inputs by the same year
It urged East African lawmakers to back the 2026 East African Legislative Assembly Agroecology Bill, and asked the African Development Bank to stop labelling industrial agriculture “climate-smart”.
Fifteen African countries have developed or are developing national agroecology strategies, and 20 governments and regional blocs have joined the Agroecology Coalition, the report said.
The findings come from a scoping study by researchers Martin Oulu and Wale Olayide for ActionAid, based on literature review, field data from Kenya, Nigeria and Zimbabwe, and interviews and surveys. The study has not been published separately.
